Best Bay Rum Aftershave Reviews

Disclaimer: We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, that at no cost to you, we may receive a small commission if you purchase through our link on this page. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you if you use our links, we really appreciate it!

Here is what the reviews say about some of the best bay rum aftershaves available on today’s market. There is just something about the scent or at least the idea of bay rum aftershaves that makes men feel more manly.

Perhaps, it is the fact that this scent is associated with those old time barbershops where getting a shave and a splash of aftershave was a real treat, or perhaps it is simply the spicy scent of these aftershaves that makes men feel more manly.

Whatever it is about their scent, they are widely sought after scents with most men looking to find a good bay rum aftershave. So, let’s see some of the more popular options.

Pinaud-Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum Review

Pinaud-Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum

Just the name Pinaud-Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum makes a person think of pirates, kegs of rum and spices, and so it is difficult not to be caught up in the excitement of trying an aftershave with such a name! Features of it include:

  • Comes in 12 ounce bottle
  • All purpose fragrance
  • Cools and refreshes

A look at a bottle of this aftershave product, and you instantly expect that it will have the distinct scent of bay oils and other exotic spices, which is exactly how the manufacturers describe this aftershave.


After a long and frustrating search for its ingredients, they proved as difficult to find as a secret pirates lair. There seems to be little ingredient information to be found concerning this product, other than the fact that it contains alcohol and has been described as having a warm, woodsy and spicy scent.

What the Reviews Say

Reviews for Pinaud-Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum are quite positive with the vast majority of users who purchased this product really liking it.

There were a few of them stating that the aftershave burns, and a few who didn’t really enjoy the scent. However, most people found several benefits in using it including:

Really wakes you up in the Morning: Several users said that this product really makes you wake up in the morning, both from the sting of the alcohol and the scent of this aftershave.

Tones and refreshes Skin: Men do feel that it tones and refreshes their skin leaving it looking and feeling better.

Lingering Traditional Scent: Most people mention that this is a traditional bay rum scent which lingers for hours and in some cases throughout the day.

Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum Aftershave Pour Review

Captain's Choice Original Bay Rum Aftershave Pour

Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum Aftershave Pour comes in a well designed brown bottle featuring a bay leaf on the label. Some of its features are:

  • Comes in a 4 ounce bottle
  • Made with natural ingredients
  • Clove free
  • Made in the USA

This product has a mild, but naturally spicy fragrance that smells masculine without being overpowering.


  • Pure grain alcohol
  • Witch Hazel
  • Rum
  • Essential oils and extracts
  • Glycerin

What the Reviews Say

Overall reviews for Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum Aftershave Pour are very positive with the main complaint about this aftershave being that its scent is more mild than expected.

However, users did experience a number of benefits from using it and these are:

Tightens Pores: People liked the fact that it helps to tighten pores making it more difficult for dirt to enter in their skin.

Rich but Mild Scent: Men found that its scent was extremely rich though mild, giving them the lingering scent of bay rum almost all day.

Reduces Razor Burn: While this aftershave might sting when first applied, it quickly cools and reduces that razor burn and irritation.

Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Cologne Review

Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Cologne

The cobalt blue bottle that this Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Cologne comes in may throw you off a bit as it is not exactly what most people think a bottle of bay rum or bay rum aftershave or cologne should look like, but don’t let the brightness of the bottle fool you.

This cologne/aftershave has all the spices you would expect from bay rum. Features of this cologne include:

  • Comes in a cobalt blue bottle with a special card
  • 8 ounce quantity
  • Bold refreshing fragrance
  • Spicy scent combined with citrus


Witch Hazel, purified water, bay oils, oils of clove bud, lime, sage, rosemary, ginger, orange, cinnamon leaf, wintergreen.

Although the list of ingredients does not state that this product contains alcohol, it does. Also, because essential oils tend to float to the top of the bottle, you need to shake this aftershave well before each use to avoid getting a shot of pure oil, or pure alcohol.

What the Reviews Say

Reviews for Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Cologne are overall quite positive. As with any aftershave, there are some users who don’t like the scent, and others who either find it too oily, or think that it burns when applied.

However, overall most of them like the burn and find these other additional benefits:

Nice Lingering Scent: People say that once this aftershave is applied, the scent seems to change to one that is spicy and refreshing which lingers for several hours making it unnecessary to have to apply cologne.

Soothing: Once the burn is gone, men actually find that this product is quite soothing to their skin.

GABELS Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion Review

GABELS Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion

GABELS is a family run business that has been making their bay rum aftershave lotion since 1932. This lotion comes in just the type of bottle you would expect something with bay rum in the title to come in. So, let’s see some of its features:

  • Comes in 16 ounce bottle
  • Brisk and refreshing scent
  • Cools


SD alcohol 40, Water, Sucrose Octacetate, Bay Oil, FD&C yellow number 5.
This product has a very light scent and so it is recommended that along with splashing it on your face, you can also splash it on shoulders and chest.

What the Reviews Say

Reviews and ratings for GABELS Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion are quite good. The only real complaint is that the scent doesn’t last as long as with most other aftershaves. However, benefits people have experienced are:

Soothes blade abrasions: Users find that this lotion really soothes the irritation cause by shaving, leaving their face feeling cooler and less irritated.

Classic subtle Scent: It is perfect for those men who prefer classic over trendy scents and want something that is refreshing but, not overpowering.

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash For Men by Barberry Coast

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash For Men by Barberry Coast

If you are looking for that great Bay Rum scent in an aftershave that contains all natural ingredients then Barberry Coast’s Bay Rum aftershave may be worth trying. This aftershave has the following features:

  • Comes in an attractive yet manly 4 ounce bottle.
  • Made from handcrafted, natural and premium ingredients.
  • No synthetic chemicals or artificial fragrances.
  • No GMO oils or parabens and is vegan friendly.
  • Contains glycerin to help prevent skin from drying out.


Alcohol, glycerin, bay, cinnamon, clove Allspice and purified water.

It should be noted that while this Bay Rum aftershave like most aftershaves does contain alcohol as the main ingredient, it also contains glycerin to help offset the drying effect of the alcohol and help you skin retain more moisture.

What the Reviews Say

Reviews and ratings for this aftershave are quite positive. While like most products containing fragrance there are some men who like the scent of this aftershave and those who do not.

However, in the case of this Bay Rum aftershave the biggest complaint about the scent of this product is not the actual scent, which most men really enjoy (as do their wives and girlfriends) but rather the fact that scent does not last all day.

However users find other benefits from using this aftershave including:

Natural Ingredients: With more and more people wanting to protect their overall health, many men really like the fact that this aftershave contains no synthetic chemicals or parabens. They like the fact that this aftershave may be healthier for their skin in the long run.

Wakes up the Skin: Users also like the fact that there is enough alcohol in this aftershave combined with other spices to really wake up their skin when they splash it on.

Helps Relieve Irritation: Users also find that the glycerin in this bay rum aftershave helps to soothe and leave the skin feeling more supple and healthier.

Finding the best Bay Rum aftershave is a matter of your own personal preference and these products may offer some good place to start in your search for the perfect Bay Rum aftershave to spice up your morning routine.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply:

buy levitra buy levitra online